Top Bar Menu
MailFacebookTwitterLinkedin
Login
VerifeedVerifeed
Verifeed
Strategic Social Intelligence
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team
    • Mission | Vision | Values
  • What We Do
    • Verifeed: Consulting Retainers and Strategic Social Playbooks
    • Return on Authenticity™
  • Why It Matters
    • Case StudiesDiscover ways how Verifeed uncovered valuable information for its clients:
      • Find My ‘Believers’
      • Predictive Insights
      • Anyone for a #SwimBikeRun?
      • Knowing the Power of Influence
      • Who Needs a Hug?
      • A Market We Didn’t Know We Had!
      • Turning a Negative into a Positive
  • Blog
  • Contact
 
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team
    • Mission | Vision | Values
  • What We Do
    • Verifeed: Consulting Retainers and Strategic Social Playbooks
    • Return on Authenticity™
  • Why It Matters
    • Case StudiesDiscover ways how Verifeed uncovered valuable information for its clients:
      • FIND MY ‘BELIEVERS’
      • PREDICTIVE INSIGHTS
      • Anyone for a #SwimBikeRun?
      • Knowing the Power of Influence
      • Who Needs a Hug?
      • A Market We Didn’t Know We Had!
      • Turning a Negative into a Positive
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Lenovo: Fame to Shame over Superfish

Lenovo falls far, and fast, as angry customers amplify their "Superfish" betrayal to millions of their closest friends on Twitter.

December 10, 2015Leave a commentInfluencer MarketingBy Melinda Wittstock

By Cathryn Atkinson and Melinda Wittstock

Trust, once lost, is hard to win back, as the Chinese computer giant Lenovo and its Silicon Valley “adware” partner Superfish have been learning to their immense cost.

After all, nothing lights up Twitter faster than a tech product gone bad – especially when it involves such an epic breach of trust.

When news broke on February 4th that Lenovo was pre-installing its laptops and smartphones with readily hackable adware that opened customers up to dangerous security and privacy breaches, the social media backlash was as swift and condemning as Lenovo’s glacial pace at delivering a non-apology apology.

Lenovo fell far, and fast, as angry customers amplified their betrayal to millions of their closest friends on Twitter and beyond. The top 10 Twitter influencers Tweeting about the Superfish “betrayal” actively engaged 75,328,719 people in just 16 days.

Incredibly, the company took exactly that long to respond, an eternity in social media terms. Once ranked by the Reputation Institute as one of the world’s most reputable companies, Lenovo didn’t respond to the Superfish mess until February 20th.

And when Lenovo did finally respond, there were only six Tweets from the company’s official @Lenovo handle, and only one of them, in a response to a customer’s direct challenge, said, “We apologize”. In fact, Lenovo initially defended the installation as a helpful tool for online shoppers before the furor made senior execs take notice.

Verifeed turned on the entire Twitter “firehose” for one month – from January 20 to February 22 – to analyze and pattern Tweets for a “before and after” portrait of what happens to good companies gone bad.

What we found was the volume of Tweets more than doubled once news broke of the Superfish malware, with 90,127 largely positive Tweets in the two weeks before Superfish and 136,284 mostly negative Tweets in the two weeks after.

The proportion of negative Tweets amplified across the social network via Re-Tweets grew almost three times as much after the breach of trust was revealed.

Think about this: With 2,175 Tweets between them, the top 10 influencers on the Superfish malware mess engaged more than 172,005,985 people who Re-Tweeted the overwhelmingly negative messages to their followers, who re-tweeted to their followers, and well, you get the picture.

To put this in perspective, before the malware news broke, Tweets about Lenovo were overwhelmingly positive – whether about its strong financial results announced February 3 or special offers, paid promotions and special offers being shared by upwards of 91 million on Twitter in the month analyzed by Verifeed.

Bad News Overshadows Good

The chatter varied from anger and insults, to straight news and information to help affected Lenovo customers. The Tweets and Retweets peaked on Feb. 20 and 21.

Before and After Superfish: The most resonating Tweets criticize the PC-maker

Or another way to look at it: 22 of the top 30 most shared Tweets in the two weeks before and after – those that inspired ongoing conversations and amplified to millions – were links to news articles in Wired, Slate and others lambasting Lenovo for Superfish.

“Lenovo’s Response to Its Dangerous Adware Is Astonishingly Clueless http://t.co/wnfc2X8W9F,” @newsycombinator Tweeted to engage 4,102,008 via Re-Tweets.

“The single worst thing I’ve seen a manufacturer do to its customer”. A furious dissection of the Lenovo scandal http://t.co/qDQ2ksTEDc”, @rhodri shared with 1,878,943.

“I try to express the sheer extremity of Lenovo’s customer betrayal with #Superfish. I still understate it.http://t.co/U9fxOJxKBi,” tech blogger and software engineer @AuerbachKeller to another 1,415,386.

As Lenovo’s reputation was being ravaged across all social media, blogging and traditional channels through the day on February 4, the company operated “business as usual”, continuing to run paid promoted Tweets, special offers and regular customer interactions.

Lenovo on Twitter the day the Superfish scandal broke: It would take 16 days for the company to apologize.

Finally on February 20th, this Tweet from Lenovo:

RT @lenovoUS: @NeighborOfBrak @lenovo We sincerely apologize for this, & given your history w/ us, we hope you’ll give us chance to prove ourselves again.

Too little, too late, and now into March, the company catching up on apologies (a bit) while still being criticized by angry consumers.

How much the breach of trust will impact its bottom line, denting its $253m net profit in the quarter to December 2014, will be seen next quarter, likely a very costly mistake compared to the reported $250,000 it made from the deal to pre-install Superfish.

So what now for Lenovo?

How hard will it be to amplify positive steps taken by the chastened company on social media and repair the damage?

People who have placed the details of the most personal aspects of their lives on Lenovo computers will certainly think twice about whether Lenovo deserves their trust.

In an era where people live much of their personal and professional lives through their computers and mobile devices – and are quick to criticize on social media when it all goes wrong, companies should be cognizant the consumer is in the driving seat. Lose your reputation for trust – or fail to act fast to restore it – and the results will show up in the P&L.

#socialmediaadwarebig datacomputer engineeringcomputer sciencecrisis managementcrisis PRcyber securitydata scienceidentity theftLenovomalwareMan in the MiddleMITMprivacyreputation managementsecuritysocial datasocial listeningsocial mediasocial media marketingSuperfishThinkpadTwitterYoga3
Share this post
FacebookTwitterGoogle+PinterestLinkedIn
About the author

Melinda Wittstock

Melinda has helped countless companies find their "believer" customers, accelerate conversions and build valuable brand buzz. She's a "recovering journalist", data science nerd, serial entrepreneur, and social media maven. Her personal mission to to help one million entrepreneurs, solopreneurs and small business owners achieve wild success!

You may also like
What’s Your ROA™?
March 3, 2017
Your Personal Brand – on Twitter
October 21, 2015
Getting girls to code
February 25, 2015
Who’s influencing
January 8, 2015
The social data
January 8, 2015
Yellow Nail Polish
January 8, 2015
Leave Comment

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

clear formSubmit

ABOUT VERIFEED

who-we-are

SEEKING VALUABLE INTELLIGENCE IS IN OUR DNA

Verifeed was founded by serial entrepreneur Melinda Wittstock. Her ability to ask revealing questions led to an award-winning career in journalism with the Times of London, BBC, CNBC and ABC.

Find Out More

BLOG CATEGORIES
  • Best Practices(9)
  • Business Innovation(9)
  • Featured on Home Page(4)
  • Influencer Marketing(7)
  • Predictive Intelligence(7)
  • Return on Authenticity™(4)
FEATURED POSTS
  • Are you a Conversion Fanatic?
    May 10, 2017
  • What’s Your ROA™?
    March 3, 2017
  • Don’t Sell! (If You Want Sales from Social)
    November 14, 2015
  • Your Personal Brand – on Twitter
    October 21, 2015
  • Growing Customers with Twitter
    October 10, 2015
  • Getting girls to code
    February 25, 2015
RECENT POSTS
  • Attn: Entrepreneurs and Visionary Innovators
  • Being Authentic in a “Fake News” World
  • Concierge Moments in a C2B World
  • Are you a Conversion Fanatic?
  • What’s Your ROA™?
  • Beyond Vanity Metrics: What’s Your Return from Social Media?
BLOG ARCHIVES
  • August 2017 (1)
  • June 2017 (1)
  • May 2017 (2)
  • March 2017 (1)
  • June 2016 (2)
  • May 2016 (1)
  • April 2016 (1)
  • March 2016 (1)
  • February 2016 (2)
  • January 2016 (1)
  • December 2015 (2)
  • November 2015 (3)
  • October 2015 (2)
  • March 2015 (1)
  • February 2015 (1)
  • January 2015 (19)
TAG CLOUD
#blacklivesmatter #socialmedia authenticity banking banks big data brand CEO computer engineering computer science crisis management customer acquisition data science Facebook finance free webinar gratitude growthhacking influencer influencers influencer targeting instagram lead gen lead generation linkedin personal brand personal branding pinterest reputation management Return on Authenticity ROA small business small business owners snapchat social Social CEO social data social listening social marketing social media social media marketing social media optimization thanksgiving Twitter webinar
ABOUT VERIFEED
who-we-are
SEEKING VALUABLE INTELLIGENCE IS IN OUR DNA
As an award-winner journalist, Melinda saw the value of understanding and forecasting business trends based on conversations people were having on social media. She used this insight to create Verifeed so that businesses could develop powerful predictive strategies.

CONNECT with VERIFEED:

Find us on:

FacebookTwitterLinkedinMail
RECENT TWEETS
  • The numbers always tell the story of a business and yet all too often women entrepreneurs shy away from knowing the… https://t.co/9nkofalorMyesterday
  • Entrepreneurship is an art, its very essence the art of creation and innovation. So when a financial whiz, banker,… https://t.co/mSiGcw41Yo5 days ago
  • How much time do you spend on social media, sharing your life’s highlight reel or promoting your business? And h… https://t.co/aSHmpaIj6b6 days ago
USEFUL INFORMATION
  • Who We Are
  • What We Do
  • Why It Matters
  • Case Studies
  • Tell Me More
  • Exclusive Masterclass
  • Verifeed’s Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Verifeed
Copyright © 2018 Verifeed, LLC - All Rights Reserved.

Digital BlueMoon